When parents go through a divorce or separation, child custody and visitation arrangements become important parts of the process. In New York, courts aim to make decisions that reflect the best interests of the child. Substance abuse, whether it’s alcohol or drugs, can have a significant effect on a parent’s ability to gain custody or visitation rights. Courts carefully consider how substance abuse affects a parent’s ability to care for their child and keep them safe. This issue can complicate custody decisions and alter visitation arrangements, especially when it comes to ensuring the child’s well-being. At, Jean M. Mahserjian, Esq., P.C, we are here to guide you through the legal process and help you navigate the complexities of your case.
How Courts View the Best Interests of the Child
In New York, the court’s primary focus is the best interests of the child. This means that judges consider factors that affect the child’s safety, stability, and emotional well-being when deciding custody and visitation matters. A parent’s substance abuse problem is a factor that is taken very seriously. Courts are cautious about placing a child in a home environment that may expose them to harm or instability due to drug or alcohol use. Substance abuse can impact a parent’s judgment, decision-making, and ability to provide proper care.
A parent who is involved in substance abuse may be seen as unfit to make responsible decisions about the child’s needs, schooling, health care, and emotional development. The court will evaluate how the substance abuse affects the parent’s ability to maintain a safe home environment and meet the child’s physical and emotional needs. The severity and extent of the substance abuse problem can impact the court’s decision.
How Substance Abuse Can Affect Custody Determinations
Custody refers to both physical custody, where the child will live, and legal custody, which relates to making decisions about the child’s upbringing. Substance abuse can influence both types of custody in different ways. For instance, if one parent is found to be using drugs or alcohol excessively, the court may decide to award sole physical custody to the other parent. This means that the child will live primarily with the parent who is not engaging in substance abuse, and the other parent may have limited visitation rights.
The court may also decide that the parent who struggles with substance abuse should not have legal custody, which would prevent them from making major decisions regarding the child’s life. This is because substance abuse can impair a parent’s judgment, making it difficult for them to make sound decisions about the child’s education, medical care, and overall welfare. In severe cases, the court may even restrict the parent from having any unsupervised contact with the child.
The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable. They truly care about their clients and walk you through the process every step of the way. I highly recommend Jean and here team for any legal needs.– Joseph B.
Was a real advocate for me while going through my divorce. Responded to emails and calls promptly and guided me through the entire process. Fair, responsive and frankly a light during a tough time.– Melissa W.
Supervised Visitation and Substance Abuse
In some cases, courts may allow a parent with substance abuse issues to have visitation with the child, but these visits may be supervised. Supervised visitation means that the parent is allowed to spend time with their child only when a responsible adult or professional supervisor is present. This is done to protect the child from any potential harm or negative effects that may arise from the parent’s substance abuse. Supervisors can be family members, or in some cases, the court will assign a professional to oversee the visits.
Supervised visitation allows the parent to maintain a relationship with their child while also ensuring that the child’s safety is not compromised. It is often viewed as a temporary solution until the parent is able to demonstrate that they have taken steps to address their substance abuse problems. The court will likely review the situation periodically to assess whether the supervised visits should continue or if the parent can move to unsupervised visits.
Rehabilitation and Regaining Custody or Visitation Rights
Parents who struggle with substance abuse are not necessarily permanently denied custody or visitation rights. In New York, the courts often give parents an opportunity to seek treatment and demonstrate their commitment to overcoming their addiction. If a parent enters a rehabilitation program and completes it successfully, they may be able to request a modification of the custody or visitation arrangement.
The court will typically look for evidence that the parent has made meaningful changes in their life, such as completing substance abuse counseling, attending support groups, and maintaining sobriety for a significant period of time. If the court is satisfied that the parent has taken steps to address their substance abuse issues, they may grant the parent increased visitation time or even consider joint custody if it is in the best interest of the child.
However, the process of regaining custody or visitation rights after dealing with substance abuse can be challenging. Parents must show the court that they have made a lasting commitment to staying sober and that they can provide a stable and safe environment for their child. This often requires regular testing for drugs or alcohol, as well as consistent participation in recovery programs. The parent must also be able to demonstrate that their substance abuse will not interfere with their ability to care for and support their child.
Related Videos
How long does a Divorce take?
What is a no Fault Divorce in NY?
The Role of Drug and Alcohol Testing in Custody Cases
In cases where substance abuse is a concern, the court may order the parent to undergo regular drug or alcohol testing. These tests are used to monitor the parent’s sobriety and ensure that they are not continuing to use drugs or alcohol. Courts may require random drug testing, scheduled testing, or testing before and after visitation periods. This helps the court verify that the parent is not engaging in substance abuse while caring for the child.
Failure to comply with drug and alcohol testing can have serious consequences in a custody case. If a parent refuses to submit to testing or tests positive for substances, the court may restrict or deny visitation rights altogether. On the other hand, if the parent consistently passes the tests, it can help build a case for increased custody or visitation time. The court wants to see evidence that the parent is maintaining their sobriety and is committed to providing a safe and stable environment for their child.
How Substance Abuse Allegations Are Handled in Custody Disputes
In some custody disputes, one parent may accuse the other of substance abuse in an attempt to influence the court’s decision. It is important to understand that these allegations must be supported by evidence for the court to take action. Courts in New York will not automatically assume that a parent is engaging in substance abuse simply based on accusations. Instead, the court will look for proof, such as police reports, arrest records, witness testimony, or results from drug and alcohol testing.
If there is credible evidence that a parent is involved in substance abuse, the court will take steps to protect the child’s well-being. However, false accusations can backfire. If a parent makes unfounded claims about the other parent’s substance abuse in an attempt to sway the court, it can damage their credibility and negatively impact their own custody case. Judges do not look favorably on parents who try to manipulate the legal process by making false claims about substance abuse or other issues.
Protecting Your Rights and the Child’s Well-Being
Parents involved in custody disputes should be aware of the impact that substance abuse can have on their case. Whether you are a parent struggling with substance abuse or the other parent is facing these issues, it is important to approach the situation with the child’s best interests in mind. Courts in New York take substance abuse very seriously because it can affect the safety, stability, and well-being of the child.
If you are dealing with substance abuse issues, seeking help through rehabilitation programs and showing the court that you are committed to recovery is key to maintaining your custody or visitation rights. On the other hand, if the other parent’s substance abuse is putting your child at risk, gathering evidence and presenting it to the court is essential for protecting your child’s safety.
In either case, navigating the legal system can be complex, and having an experienced attorney to guide you through the process is critical to achieving a positive outcome.
If you are facing a custody dispute involving substance abuse, it is important to seek legal advice from a knowledgeable family law attorney. At Mahserjian & Mahserjian-Ortiz, PLLC, our dedicated legal team understands the challenges that substance abuse can present in custody and visitation cases. We are here to help you protect your rights and ensure that your child’s best interests are always at the forefront. Contact us today to discuss your case and learn how we can assist you in navigating the complexities of New York family law.
